Not resolved

I was sitting down tonight enjoying a bowl of Breyer's ice cream, Reese's Blast to be exact.I was chomping on the bits of chocolate cups with my front teeth, when I bit into something hard.

I spit out a small piece of black plastic into my hand. Not sure where this came from, as I used a large metal spoon to dish out the ice cream. I also checked our ice cream scoop to make sure nothing was broken on it, as my son or girlfriend may have used it to dish out their ice cream.

Nothing on the scoop is broken or missing.Not quite sure where to go from here, as I am dissatisfied with my experience...not looking to sue or anything like that...just would like an explanation.

Review about: Breyers Ice Cream.

Had an Experience with Breyers?

Write a review


Terms of Service
Post Comment
Asheboro, North Carolina, United States #1312259

Just found 4 clear plastic or glass objects in my "birthday celebration" ice cream! Apparently this is a problem Breyers thought would go away. What do you guys think about class action??


I just sat down with a new bryers ice cream and I just bit into hard plastic and broke my tooth I'm in shock I've never had anything like this happen so I looked up bryers and found this site I don't know what to do


Having problems with Gelato buckets. I have called three times as the lids are broken and or cracked un the tamper seal.


I just had the same thing happen to me eating Breyers Rasberry Cheesecake Gelato.Black and white strings of plastic about .5 to 1 inch long on April 19.

I plan to contact them per the post below.

I've bought 4 containers of their Gelato products this week.

to Techlady 33 #810010

Wife and I just had the same thing happen in the triple chocolate Gelato except our piece plastic with .25 x 1.25 inches green plastic with white arrows.Looks like pull strip or something from ingredients.

Called Unilever product safety number and they took a report and we're very pleasant about the whole thing.We'll see what comes of it.


I found a piece of black plastic in my cookie dough ice cream on Thursday Jan 17th but didn't call them the following day as I had my wisdom teeth removed.Today I was back to eating the ice cream (not the chocolate) :( and voila!!

another piece of plastic. I had forgotten about the first piece and now I have 2 pieces to provide them with and the containers not even empty.

I mistook the plastic for chocolate chips as it was the same colour.I too have pics and they look identical.


I can get a syringe and put it next to a tube of ice cream but that does not mean it was in there. If that piece of plastic was really in the container it would not be that clean. Nice try though.

to Jedi Knight Ethan Topeka, Kansas, United States #951872

The original poster did say it was in his mouth. Im pretty sure most of us would have cleaned it up to see what it was. It doesnt have to be dirty to exist.

to Jedi Knight Ethan Hyattsville, Maryland, United States #1240193

Their are lots of people complaining about finding small plastic bits in their ice cream recently...im sure not all are on the level, but with so many reporting it, something has to be going on..even though this is an old post


Dont mind the plastic that is one of the ingredients in the 'natural flavors'.

You May Also Like

Breyers Butter Pecan Ice Cream Breyers "Recently purchased Breyers ice cream for company during dinner. To my dismay, we couldn't find any pecan nuts. I thought as I dug deeper, surely some would show up...." Read more Breyers - Mrs Fields Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough Ice Cream Review from Huntley, Illinois Breyers "I completely agree with the misleading packaging. I recently purchased Mrs. Fields Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough. I took pictures. The "chunks" shown on the package, weren't even "chunks" at all...." Read more Breyers - Ice Cream Review from Aledo, Texas Breyers "Sooo Excited you finally came out with Chocolate Lactose Free Ice Cream!!! I do enjoy the vanilla with lots of chocolate syrup of course.I have only bein able to find..." Read more Breyers - Cookies And Cream Ice Cream Review from Houston, Texas Breyers "We have been buying their cookies and cream ice cream for years. Tonight when I went to open the one we had just bought, the whole center of it was..." Read more DiggyPOD - Formatting Errors in Edgar's Handbook DiggyPOD "End of January 2017 I wrote my 3rd book. Felt I was being sold revisions for $40 each time by Valerie. My book started out an 8 X 11 and..." Read more Discount Tire Store Txh56 On 2927 Southwest Fwy 77098 - Took almost 3 hours to service a tire. Discount Tire Store Txh56 On 2927 Southwest Fwy 77098 "I arrive at 11:15 AM. They let me know my truck is ready at 1:50 PM and told me I have to pay for a new warranty. They replace the..." Read more Shopify - Scam/Rip Off Shopify " I ordered two bras off the website. Got a email confirmation of my order never got a tracking number emailed customer service never got a reply over a month..." Read more Safeco Insurance - Safeco Claims the WORST EVER Safeco Insurance "On July 11th, 2017 we noticed that our hardwood floor in our kitchen and hall had erupted due to a water leak at the refrigerator. The continuous hardwood floor consists..." Read more